Pages

Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Egypt. Show all posts

Saturday, 27 July 2013

Video: Revolt and imperialism in the Arab world

This is from last weekend's Counterfire day school in London. It is my introduction (and summing-up) for a session on revolt and imperialism in the Arab world.

I was originally asked to talk about Syria for 15 minutes, with someone else speaking on Egypt for the same amount of time, so that between us we would do justice to the title. But the other speaker had to withdraw and, although I somewhat adapted my notes, this explains the unmistakable bias towards Syria here.

Friday, 5 July 2013

Egypt - what next for the revolution?


Tahrir square on 3 July. Photo: GIANLUIGI GUERCIA/AFP/Getty Images
There are many things to be said about Egypt right now. I want here to focus on the 'what is to be done?' question. There are  different views and emphases (among the left) on the matter of how the revolution can be advanced.

How can the left win the political struggle inherent in the revolutionary movement? Can the revolution become a socialist revolution? If so, how?


Strengths and limits of the movement

The strategic question rests upon an understanding of the strengths and limitations of what is already happening. There have been mass mobilisations and a militant wave of strikes. It is the self-activity of mainly working class protesters and strikers that has driven the whole process and created the context for the removal of Morsi. I heard an Egyptian commentator on the radio referring to it as "a popular impeachment of the president", stressing the revolutionary dynamic, the movement from below.

This is worth re-asserting because there are those who mistakenly perceive this week's events as a step backwards, with a one-sided view of a military coup removing a democratically elected government. Such a view is all form and no content, missing the actual dynamic of events. It fails to grasp that the army's actions are driven by (an entirely justified) fear of further mass action from below, and the threat it poses.

But there is an opposite kind of one-sided view, which is equally mistaken. This emphasises only the mass action, characterising the downfall as Morsi as a fairly uncomplicated 'second revolution' after the revolutionary movement that brought down Mubarak, and therefore a straightforward advance. This view misses something of fundamental importance: the vital issue of political direction and leadership. Every revolutionary process becomes divided and contested politically, however (relatively) unified it may be at the outset.

The immense danger is that the army top brass demobilises the revolution and directs it into the dead end of superficial reform which fails to address the deep-seated social and economic grievances of millions of Egyptians. The army is - without wanting to state the obvious - not an expression of the popular will, but an institution of the state, of the old order. The generals are subject to popular pressure, but they have acted to 'manage' the mass movement and not advance its interests.

The revolution is driven from below, but its political expression (in the removal of Morsi, arrests of numerous Brotherhood officials, etc) is managed from above. Many of those on the streets understandably celebrated the army's actions in removing Morsi, as they felt it was a consequence of their own actions, and there is a revival of the notion that 'the people and the army are one hand'. But there also appears to be some tensions in the mass movement, as many protesters recall the army's many abuses of power in the period following Mubarak's downfall and feel uneasy about allowing the generals to co-opt a popular uprising.

The coup therefore reflects both strength and weakness: the strength of a revolutionary struggle forcing the generals to act, but the weakness of a mass movement that relies on a section of the existing state to remove the target of the movement's anger.

It is necessary to grasp these contradictions, to see what is happening as a profoundly unstable process not a single coherent event. What happens is up for grabs, not settled or pre-ordained. The army elite's interests are deeply opposed to those of the mass of people, both in terms of democracy and a range of social and economic questions. The contradictions are unlikely to be easily resolved.

Politics is central  

But we need to be clear that the army is attempting to settle these contradictions in a particular direction. If this is to be resisted, what is required? It is not enough to simply say that the mobilisations must continue. Of course they must, but that doesn't address the problem. It is possible for the mobilisations to continue, but without posing a political and democratic alternative to the army elite.

I have seen two ideas in particular come to the fore in radical-left commentary. One is the emphasis on rising strike activity and the notion that a general strike can be the decisive breakthrough. An even higher level of strike action would indeed be an advance, but it would still be entirely insufficient. It does not directly challenge the rule of the army or address the question of political leadership.

Similarly, there is the idea that the left needs a mass political party. This reflects a correct understanding that the action on the streets and in the workplaces requires political expression, that on its own it will not suffice. But it would be a mistake to reduce politics to the electoral sphere, especially when the struggle is finding its primary expression on the streets and not at the ballot box. Electoral politics can be a useful strand to the revolutionary process, but it is only one strand and it won't be the decisive one.

It can easily become a detour for the mass movement - a key argument in the weeks ahead from those seeking a 'stabilising' of 'order' will be along the lines of 'leave the streets and the squares, go home and wait for elections so you can have your say through the democratic process'. This deploys the rhetoric of democracy with the aim of limiting the meaning of democracy - limiting it to putting a cross on a ballot paper. It is their version of democracy not ours - a 'democracy' that will fail to deliver real changes for the mass of people and breed further disillusionment.

Yet there are different visions of democracy and the revolution has articulated a more radical, far-reaching notion, which encompasses the mass action of the people and extends to the workplaces. This is what terrifies the elite, including the generals who moved against Morsi, and they will use the narrow 'democratic process' precisely to defeat broader and deeper notions of democracy.

We should also remember two other things here. There is now widespread mistrust of political parties in Egypt, as expressed in the movement against the Muslim Brotherhood-backed Morsi. And there is the problem of unity, with the proliferation of numerous different parties of one stripe or another. If the revolutionary movement is to develop a political alternative to the army and those 'pro-reform' elements of the ruling class, it must rapidly develop its own forms of organisation - rooted and embedded in the movement of the streets, the square and the workplaces, not separated from it and diverting energy away from it.

Popular assemblies - the missing ingredient

There is no fixed blueprint for what this will look like, no exact model from earlier struggles elsewhere that can be replicated. It is, however, a need that naturally arises in every serious mass revolutionary movement: how can the people organise and represent themselves in order to advance their struggle? In every major revolution there has been some sort of form of democratic, popular organisation, most famously the soviets in the Russian revolutions of  1905 and 1917 but there are many other examples.

The level of mobilisation in Egypt has been - and continues to be - remarkably high, even by the standards of revolutions. It is significant that the process has continued and, more than two years after Mubarak's demise, it is possible for mass action to happen on such a scale as we are seeing now. It should also be noted that the revolution has addressed (and continues to address) social and economic questions, and it continuously involves militant strike action.

This all provides a strong basis for the Egyptian equivalent of the soviets, yet there has been relatively little in the way of such developments. That has to change if there is to be hope for the revolution. Who is driving the political direction of the revolution? It can only be the people actually doing the protesting if they develop their own democratic forms. If there is a vacuum here, opportunist elements (from the generals to moderates like ElBaradei) will move to fill it.

This question can be viewed at a number of levels. Above all, there is the simple fact that the growth of revolutionary assemblies is essential if there is to ever be a challenge for state power, i.e. if the revolution is to confront not only one particular form of capitalist rule, but the whole structure.

But there is an urgency to the task that derives from more mundane, day-to-day matters. Numerous demands are arising in the course of struggle. The movement's participants correctly grasp that their own activity is essential to winning those demands. However, what is not yet clear to many is that their own political organisations are necessary to amplify the calls for those demands, to co-ordinate the struggles, and to articulate a more or less coherent political alternative to the moderate elements promoted by a jittery ruling class.

It is in the course of constructing such alternative sites of political organisation, discussion and co-ordination that the popular will can find an expression which does it justice. This is how people's interests can be advanced rather than curtailed. It is, fundamentally, a question of class - the army's power is part of a capitalist order which preserves the wealth of tiny minority, at the expense of the majority, regardless of the changes in political order. Egypt's working class needs an alternative rooted in its mass protests and strike waves.

A political struggle for the future

Popular assemblies are, furthermore, the only way to ensure the activist minority connects itself to the many millions of Egyptians at home, at work, going about their daily business. Even when demonstrations are on the sensational scale seen in the last week, it is still a minority of the population.

Democratic forms are required which not only organise and co-ordinate the protesters, but which link them to many millions of people who are sympathetic but not actively involved. This is no idle fantasy when you consider the scale and depth of this revolution.

Such a development could even win over many of those currently still supportive of the Muslim Brotherhood - which, lest we forget, has previously been the dominant political tendency in the country and still retains a fragile but real social base. The more left-wing and politically independent elements in the revolutionary movement have to contest political leadership with both the Brotherhood and the elite moderates positioning themselves as advocates of the popular movement. They can potentially win the support of some of those traditionally supportive of more moderate political forces.

For socialists in the revolutionary movement, there is no greater or more urgent task than helping to create such a broad political alternative. The left is historically weak in Egypt - and is currently dwarfed by the scale of the mobilisations - but this is the challenge now.


Share

Saturday, 17 December 2011

An extraordinary year in the Arab world

Tahrir Square, Cairo: a centre of revolution in 2011
This is the first of four brief selections of my writing published on Counterfire and Luna17 this year.

Today is widely regarded as marking one year of the Arab revolutions, so I begin with north Africa and the Middle East - including missives from my trips to occupied Palestine and post-revolutionary Cairo, and concluding with a substantial article on the progress of the revolutionary movements.

The Fire This Time (September)



Share

Thursday, 29 September 2011

The Fire This Time


"The bonds between 2011's islands of youth dissent remain limited. Although the root causes of anger may be similar, the levels of politicisation among those expressing that anger vary wildly. But this year could still be remembered as one in which, after many decades of moribund political and economic realities, a new narrative began to form."

Islands of youth dissent

The above quote is from an article in The Guardian on 13 August, one week after Tottenham erupted in riots. It was called 'A hunger for change - how youth-led revolts shook elites around the world.'

These 'islands of youth dissent' include the riot-torn communities in this country, but more importantly the occupied public squares of Madrid, Athens and elsewhere. Above all, the phrase refers to the sites of revolution and popular uprisings in the Arab world - the subject of this article - where the levels of politicisation and struggle have been highest.

Paul Mason, BBC Newsnight's economics editor, has referred to 2011 as the year it all kicked off. In not only the Arab world but Greece, Spain, Chile, Wisconsin and elsewhere - even here with the student revolts, the massive TUC demonstration on 26 March, public sector strikes on 30 June (and with more to come on 30 November) - there has been a shift in the level of resistance.

The Guardian article I opened with went on:

"The philosopher who coined the term "Black Swan event" - denoting a hugely consequential event that is utterly unpredictable and can only be explained afterwards - was recently asked by Jeremy Paxman whether the violence on the streets of Athens fell into that category. He demurred - and said that the real Black Swan event was that more people weren't rioting elsewhere."

Many of the root causes of anger have indeed been similar, if to varying degrees. There are both economic and political factors at work. Economic motors of revolt include rising food prices, privatisation, growing inequality and - a key element in explaining the generational dynamics - the phenomenon of rising graduate and youth unemployment.

The sense of a 'lost generation', disproportionately victims of the economic crisis and austerity, is unmistakable. It is no coincidence that anti-austerity revolt in this country first found expression in student protests and a wave of college occupations (in November-December 2010).

Political motors of revolt vary in degree. It is true that Western democracies are different to the old authoritarian regimes of Ben Ali, Mubarak, Saleh, Al-Assad and Gaddafi. In the Arab world repression, censorship and overt authoritarian rule were crucial drivers of revolt. But in countries like Greece and Spain the revolts articulate a deep sense of alienation from political structures, of democracy having been hollowed out.

The Arab revolutions are marked by the intertwining of political struggles - focused on democracy - and economic struggles. There is a fusion of economic and political, of young protesters and workers, of the streets and the workplaces. Such fusion is hardly the exclusive preserve of Arab countries.

Tunisia and Egypt

In their new book 'The People Demand: a short history of the Arab revolutions', John Rees and Joseph Daher identify three overlapping phases in the development of the Arab revolutions.

Firstly, the victorious revolutions in Tunisia and Egypt. These saw rapid victories as a result of massive demonstrations. In both these revolutionary movements, strikes also played a critical role in the final days before the old regime fell. They were victories for the democratic revolution but also - from the start - raised economic demands.

US and western imperialism were helpless, incapable of a coherent response. Cracks in the ruling elite, including in the top brass of the armed forces, weakened the old order - and emboldened the revolutionaries.

The revolutions inspired uprisings in the wider Arab world. When I visited the occupied West Bank in late February, I asked one of our Palestinian hosts "Are you hopeful about the future of Palestine?" He said yes, so I asked why. He gave a one-word answer: "Egypt". Millions of people elsewhere in the region felt the same hope about not just Palestine, but the destiny of their own country.

The Tunisian and Egypt revolutions have in fact continued, beyond the toppling of Ben Ali on 14 January and Mubarak on 11 February, but with a sharp process of class-based and political differentiation. Moderate elements of the democratic revolution are now emphasising continuity rather than change.

There is a recurring conflict between the elites and the streets. In Cairo, it is between the army council (and its political allies) and the 'Republic of Tahrir', i.e. the alternative model of popular power and participatory democracy embodied by the protesters who keep returning to Tahrir Square.

The continuing struggles concern economics and politics. Workers have raised independent class demands, but there is also the ongoing movement for genuine democratic reform. Different visions of democracy are constantly in competition. The question is posed: their democracy or ours?

Imperialism and counter-revolution

Secondly, there was the imperialist, or counter-revolutionary, backlash. This took two main forms - and at almost exactly the same time.

In mid-March the western powers, led by France, Britain and the US, exploited weaknesses in Libya's revolution and - desiring influence in the revolutionary process, to curtail it rather than to advance it - moved in. The NATO intervention was undoubtedly a turning point, altering the character of the Libyan revolt profoundly, but also shifting the balance of forces in the broader Arab world.

You only have to observe the aftermath of the fall of Tripoli to recognise this is politically very different from the victories of January-February. The dominant elements in Libya's TNC are former members of the Gaddafi regime - these are the people with existing links to the Western powers, after all.

The bombing of Libya has resuscitated the case for 'humanitarian intervention' which was so discredited by Iraq and Afghanistan. Tony Blair feels confident about calling for 'regime change' in Iran and Syria. This is unlikely to happen, but it's a marker of the shifting ideological terrain.

Almost exactly simultaneous to the Libya intervention, Saudi troops entered Bahrain to help the Bahraini authorities crush that country's uprising. Saudi Arabia is an ally of the US and Britain, with close military, diplomatic and trade links.

While in Libya Western intervention played the key role, in Bahrain it was the neighbouring Gulf states which repressed the uprising - but with the tacit approval of the West. US defense secretary Robert Gates gave the 'green light' to US allies in the Gulf for the crushing of the Bahraini movement, at the same time as gearing up for the bombardment of Libya (supposedly to 'protect the revolution').

John Rees and Joseph Daher put it like this:

"The aim in both cases was the same: to crush and control the emerging revolutionary processes. In Bahrain this was achieved by straightforward repression. In Libya the military intervention was used to corral and control the revolutionary process. The result has been to impede the march of revolution everywhere - in Syria and Yemen, as well as in Bahrain and Libya. The dictators have dug in."

Freedom for Palestine

Thirdly, a new phase in the struggle for the liberation of Palestine has opened up. The turning point here was also mid-March. While NATO bombing of Libya and the crushing of Bahrain's uprising were setbacks for the whole movement, the "15th of March Movement" in the Occupied Palestinian Territories was a vastly more hopeful development.

The new, youth-led, movement for Palestinian unity dovetailed with developments in neighbouring Egypt. The interim regime in Egypt is under popular pressure to break from the old cosy relationship with Israel and deliver solidarity to the Palestinians. It is an issue about which millions of Egyptians are passionate.

The Egyptian regime played the pivotal role in engineering a unity deal between Fatah (dominant in the West Bank’s Palestinian Authority), Hamas (ruling party in Gaza) and other political groups. Only Egypt has such authority in the region to do this. Recent claims about Turkey's role as a regional superpower, while reflecting real forces, need to be kept in perspective.

The youth movement inside the occupied territories and the popular pro-Palestinian protests in Egypt have called for unity between Fatah and Hamas, but often also for a renewal of resistance to Israel (sometimes dubbed a ‘Third Intifada’) and for broader unity across the whole Palestinian people and the Arab world. There is pressure on the established Palestinian leadership from within the Palestinian community (notably the 15th of March movement) and from outside, in the form of a post-Mubarak Egypt.

Egypt’s revolution has opened up space in which a post-Mubarak foreign policy can be debated. The demonstrations outside Cairo’s Israeli Embassy – with the Israeli flag twice being removed by protesters as a powerful symbol of popular support for Palestine – exert pressure on the army council, which historically has close ties with the US and a conciliatory attitude to Israel.

The debate inside Egyptian society helped form the conditions in which a unity deal was possible. There are problems with it - just as there are problems with the current bid for Palestinian 'statehood' - but it nevertheless poses a serious challenge to Israel and US interests in the region. The imperial architecture of the Arab world is changing.

What next?

We can see, then, how the Arab revolutionary wave is the most acute expression of a global revolt. Driven by political authoritarianism and economic hardship, young people have played a central role, though in a broad movement which has witnessed strike waves and the emergence of new workers' organisations - as well as the mass occupations of public spaces, which have become the signature of modern youth-led revolts.

The politics of north Africa and the middle east is being re-shaped. This has profound consequences for the West, in particular for US imperialism. The heady days of revolutionary success in January-February have been followed by three processes: political differentiation in Tunisia and Egypt; the imperialist, counter-revolutionary backlash in Libya and Bahrain; and the opening of a new chapter in the movement for Palestinian freedom.

Imperialism has been weakened, but we have learnt - if we didn't know it already - that powerful Western states won't just sit back and let revolutionary change happen in the most geopolitically and strategically important region of the globe. More optimistically, it is also clear that many ordinary people in the region, especially in Egypt and Tunisia, aren't willing to settle for a modest democratic settlement which leaves most of their demands unmet.

In Egypt the revolution continues. On 9 September there was yet another huge demo in Tahrir Square, demanding those responsible for corruption and brutality in the old regime are brought to justice, and more generally pursuing the democratic demands of the 25 January Revolution. There have also been fresh strikes, across a number of sectors, during September.

Two central questions have emerged in Tunisia and Egypt. What kind of democracy are we fighting for? And can change be extended to the economic sphere?

The latter question isn't just about driving out the 'workplace Mubaraks' - corrupt, rich old bosses linked to the former regime. It is about demands for jobs, a living wage and improved workers' rights. More deeply, it concerns fundamental questions of power in a capitalist society.

These are the questions that students of past revolutions would expect to arise. Most revolutions have been limited to struggles for democratic and political reform. The degree of political change has varied, but even in South Africa - where the scale of political change was profound, with the end of apartheid - economic exploitation has remained unaltered.

The Tunisian and Egyptian revolutions have been among the deeper, more profound revolutions of modern times. Think about the vast scale of the demonstrations, the full participation of the working class, the role of strikes, the raising of far-reaching democratic demands and independent class demands, and the continuing momentum of protest since the dictators fell.

These are, furthermore, revolutions happening in a very different context to the upheavals of 1989-94. As revolts against regimes which were simultaneously neoliberal and allied to the West, their effect has been to shift the balance of forces against US imperialism and neoliberal capitalism. This is the opposite of the impact - politically, economically and ideologically - of the eastern European revolutions over two decades ago. The Libya intervention has shifted this balance in the opposite direction, but only up to a point.

In both countries there has been an element of a 'second revolution' opening up within the larger revolutionary process, one that aims at deeper democratic change and seeks to extend the revolution to economic relations, and in which the working class is central. But this process prompts very serious questions about the role of organisation and politics.

John Rees and Joseph Daher write about the necessity of two further elements, both to do with independent working class organisation:

"Working class organisation must assume a form that can challenge the state apparatus for power. And a political organisation  which popularises this perspective among workers is necessary."

To focus on Egypt, since February there have been three developments which are hopeful and extremely significant in this respect. There has been growth in independent trade unions, new left-wing political parties and grassroots popular assemblies (whether in Tahrir or in local communities). These three elements are all vital in strengthening working class organisation and creating an alternative political pole of attraction to the dominant moderate elements in the new order.

The unions need to be bigger, the left wing parties need to be bigger - and the experiments in democratic assemblies, which have been extremely sporadic, inconsistent and ad hoc, need to be become systematic and co-ordinated. In every revolution it is necessary for the more radical elements - those committed to sustaining the revolutionary process - to create institutional forms which express alternative political programmes and can, at their most advanced, pose a challenge to the power of the state.

The outcome of the revolutions is yet to be settled. Just as importantly, they have inspired and informed the character of revolts elsewhere, including in Europe. In our struggles, especially in opposition to austerity, we can expect resistance to develop in new and dynamic ways. We may yet, in this country, confront some of the same challenges alluded to above. 


Share

Sunday, 25 September 2011

'The People Demand: a short history of the Arab revolutions' - video trailer

28 September: London book launch - details HERE

12 October: Newcastle book launch - details HERE

Read an extract and buy the book HERE



Trailer by Elly Badcock

Share

Wednesday, 7 September 2011

From Mahalla to Tahrir, it's all kicking off (again)


As militant textile workers in Mahalla plan to strike indefinitely from Saturday, Egypt's Revolutionary Youth Coalition has called for a mass rally in Tahrir Square this Friday. This is re-posted from Counterfire:

'Strikes are growing here in Egypt. A post workers' strike is ongoing, with a number of other groups of workers joining the strike movement. It is estimated a quarter of a million workers will join a national strike this Saturday, 10th September. In Cairo the aim is to build on the momentum from Friday's street protests in Tahrir Square.

Textile workers from a number of towns and cities have announced they are joining Mahalla's strike on Saturday. Mahalla has been a major site of workers' unrest in recent years, especially the major textiles strikes in 2006 and 2008, widely believed to have helped lay the ground for this year's revolution.

Mahalla's public sector textile factory is the biggest factory in Egypt, employing 22,000 workers. They will all begin an open-ended strike on Saturday. Workers are demanding that Prime Minister Essam Sharif increase investment in the company, introduce a minimum wage in line with inflation and release outstanding pay cheques.

Mahalla workers issued a statement, declaring that their struggle is for not only themselves but also to win a decent standard of living for all Egyptian workers. A delegation of workers has gone to Cairo to present their demands directly to the prime minister's office.

The Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF), which currently rules the country prior to elections, has asked for a meeting with the labour leaders in Mahala. This has been refused by the workers. The prime minister is, however, going to Mahalla for the negotiations.

I've been going to the picket lines for the postal strikes and it seems they will continue until at least this Friday, 9th September. More generally, there are calls for increased co-ordination of strikes by different groups. There is potential for a general strike to be orchestrated, but it all depends on what happens in Mahalla on Saturday - and how effectively the action spreads to other areas - plus what happens in Tahrir Square on Friday.

Activists are preparing for big protests in Tahrir this Friday with various groups echoing the Revolutionary Youth Coalition's call for a mass rally. Some are demanding an immediate halt to military trials of civilians. There are also serious concerns that current planning for elections unfairly advantages the more conservative elements, including former Mubarak supporters.

It is anticipated there will be clashes with security forces on Friday. Youth activist groups have called for security personnel to be withdrawn from Tahrir on Friday, due to fears of 'bloodshed'. On Monday there were assaults by security forces on the families of the revolution's martyrs, while Mubarak's trial was in session.

Moderate Muslim Brotherhood leaders have, unsurprisingly, declared they won't participate in the Tahrir Square rally. Ahram Online reports: 'The General Secretary of the Freedom and Justice Party Saad El-Kataneny announced that the party, affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood, was not going to participate in the million-man protest to be held on 9 September 2011 in Tahrir Square'.

This isn't the first time Egypt has seen a strike movement emerge this year. In the final three days up to Mubarak's downfall on 11th February there was a rapidly growing wave of strikes, with Mahalla at the epicentre, which proved to be one of the decisive factors in forcing the president to flee. After Mubarak's downfall there were further strikes, with workers raising independent economic demands such as calls for better pay.

Mahalla workers previously played a key role for in efforts to organise beyond the limits of the state-controlled Egyptian Federation of Trade Unions. Last month growing independent labour groups forced the prime minister to agree to dismantle the executive board of the old federation. Mahalla union activist Wael Habib currently sits on a special committee designed to oversee this transition.

The majority of the labour militancy is outside Cairo, but the capital could still become a major focus. Organisation is very patchy, but there has been some development of independent workers' groups since February. There is an organised left, though it remains relatively weak. A key issue is what links can be made between the youth-led protests in Tahrir (and elsewhere) and the strikes.

Friday and Saturday are likely to be decisive in shaping the coming months. The hope is that the workers' rebellion will generalise, involving more groups of workers and greater co-ordination, representing a new phase in Egypt's revolution.'

Mahmoud Mahdy is an activist in Scotland's International Socialist Group. Additional material provided by Alex Snowdon and Feyzi Ismail.

Share

Sunday, 4 September 2011

'The People Demand: a short history of the Arab revolutions' - Newcastle book launch


Cairo's Tahrir Square during the revolution
On Wednesday 12 October John Rees will be introducing his new book The People Demand: a short history of the Arab revolutions (co-written with Joseph Daher).

The book launch, hosted by Counterfire, is upstairs at Newcastle's Salsa Cafe and starts at 7pm.

See the Facebook Event.

The Arab revolutions have started to re-shape global politics. The People
Demand traces the major developments and includes reportage from Cairo during the 18 days of revolutionary upheaval in early 2011. It analyses the mass popular movements which have overthrown regimes, shaken US imperialism, and inspired millions around the world.

This is one of the first assessments of the Arab revolutions to encompass a range of movements. These essays analyse the complex links between Tunisia, Egypt, Palestine, Libya, Bahrain and Syria, examining how the popular revolts have dramatically affected relations with the US, Israel and the West.

Through a richly detailed and perceptive account of events across the Arab world, The People Demand addresses vital questions about democracy, revolution and imperialism.

The book is published on 16 September by Counterfire, priced £6.99. Entry to the Newcastle book launch is free.  

John Rees participated in the Egyptian revolution and his eye-witness accounts are included in The People Demand. He was Vice President (Europe) of the Cairo international solidarity conferences which started in 2002.

He is a co-founder of the Stop the War Coalition and the author of The Algebra of Revolution, Imperialism and Resistance, and Strategy and Tactics. He is a member of the editorial board of Counterfire and writes and presents the Timeline political history series for the Islam Channel.

Share

Sunday, 21 August 2011

Video: Israel flag removed from Cairo embassy by protestors

'On August 20, 2011 Egyptians mobilized for a demonstration in front of the Israeli Embassy demanding the removal of the flag and for the ambassador to leave. After hours of flag-burning trials, a man called "Ahmed El-Shahat" managed to climb the embassy building and remove the Israeli flag and replace it with the Egyptian one.' The Guardian has background HERE.



Share

Thursday, 28 July 2011

Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood: is this what counter-revolution looks like?

Amid continued protest in Egypt and the formation of a new government, the Muslim Brotherhood’s position continues to be a source of debate. Joseph Daher has written a new analysis for Counterfire, which begins:

'The Muslim Brotherhood was the largest opposition party during the Mubarak era. Under the Mubarak regime, the Brotherhood was formally banned but nevertheless tolerated. The begrudging toleration, however, did not save its members from frequent arrests and trials before exceptional courts.

The group achieved its best election result in 2005 with independent candidates allied to it winning 20 percent of the seats. The government subsequently launched a crackdown on the Brotherhood, detaining hundreds of members, and instituting a number of legal "reforms" to make them illegal. During the fraud-ridden 2010 parliamentary elections, the government found pretexts to invalidate the candidacies of virtually all Muslim Brotherhood-linked independents.

The Brotherhood leadership backed the revolution from 28th January, while the youth of the party were part of the revolution since day one, from the 25th. The position of the Brotherhood towards the revolutionary process since the fall of Mubarak has been ambiguous. Many protesters in Egypt have characterized the Brotherhood’s behavior as counter-revolutionary, while others say that it is nevertheless the largest and most organised party in the country so there is a need to collaborate with it.'

Read the full article: Egypt's revolution and the Muslim Brotherhood

Share

Friday, 8 July 2011

Take to the streets: the revolution is still on

Picture by Gigi Ibrahim. Suez, 7 July.
Via The Guardian:

'Egypt's military-backed transitional government is bracing itself for the largest protest yet against its rule on Friday with plans for a "million-strong" rally to defend the revolution at Tahrir Square.

In a rare show of unity, Egypt's largest political Islamist movement, the Muslim Brotherhood, will join a vast array of liberal, leftist and secular political forces, including youth representatives from this year's anti-Mubarak uprising. They will demand that police officers and former regime officials are finally held accountable and that the army's grip over the justice system comes to an end.

"Take to the streets on July 8: the revolution is still on," reads graffiti scrawled across the Egyptian capital.

The demonstration comes at a perilous time for the authorities, following 10 days of street violence in Cairo and Suez as public frustration at the slow pace of reform begins to grow.

On Wednesday, armed security forces fought running battles with civilians, after several police officers accused of murdering protesters during the toppling of former president Hosni Mubarak earlier this year were released on bail.

"The demands of the revolution have not changed since day one," declared the 25th January Revolution Youth Coalition in an online statement calling on Egyptians to join Friday's demonstration. "It was not just about toppling the old regime but about building a state where people can have freedom, dignity, rule of law and social justice."

Read the rest HERE.

Three things are worth noting. Firstly, while the article's main focus is on Cairo today, it's acknowledged that protests are happening elsewhere (also see the picture above from Suez) - and that today's demonstrations will be building on continual protest activity in recent days.

Secondly, The Muslim Brotherhood has shifted ground since 27 May, when it publicly condemned demonstrations in Tahrir Square and elsewhere. It is under great pressure, including from many of its own youth. The Brotherhood continues to play a highly contradictory role, torn between conflicting forces in Egyptian society. Participation now is vital to maintaining credibility with millions of Egyptian people. But it follows - it doesn't lead.

Finally, the emergence of popular assemblies isn't explicitly mentioned by the Guardian but it is happening. It is difficult to assess their scope and development from afar, but socialist activists have pointed to them as a crucial innovation. These are alternative forums and organising centres that convey a a more radical notion of democracy to the modest advances of the current transitional period with its myriad frustrations and failings.

Two weeks ago I wrote about the background to this: Egyptian left organises for 8 July mass protests

Also see my report from the recent Cairo Conference.


Share

Friday, 24 June 2011

Egyptian left organises for 8 July mass protests

The Guardian reports on plans by Egyptian political and activist groups to build fresh mass demonstrations on Friday 8 July. It is informative, but doesn't entirely grasp the dynamics of what is happening. We are told:

'Egyptian activists have threatened to bring mass pro-democracy protests back to Cairo, with a "million-strong" occupation of Tahrir Square planned for 8 July unless the ruling army generals abandon their current "roadmap" to democracy. In an increasingly rancorous debate, which has developed into a proxy war between the nation's fledgling Islamist and secular political forces, 40 different liberal and leftist movements have joined forces to demand that plans to hold elections in September are dropped.'

The article overstates the extent to which what's unfolding is an Islamist vs secular conflict. It correspondingly downplays what is really crucial here, which is a conflict in visions of democracy, i.e. a political difference, one that isn't primarily concerned with Islamism.

In the continuing revolution in Egypt there are, broadly speaking, two versions of democracy competing with each other. The military council and leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood - the strongest political force, post-Mubarak - tend towards a conservative view, seeking a standard parliamentary republic like we have here in the West.

The Muslim Brotherhood is keen on early elections (September) partly for opportunistic reasons - it is well established and gains from not allowing less developed and organised forces from having time to build their influence. But its leaders also desperately want to keep control of the revolutionary process and limit it to modest democratic reforms.

The Brotherhood was an important oppositional movement during the Mubarak years, one that was viciously persecuted by a highly repressive security apparatus. It initially lagged behind the protestors during the 18 tumultuous days of revolutionary upheaval which began on 25 January, and concluded with the downfall of Hosni Mubarak on 12 February.

Those mass protests were initiated by youth and left-wing groups, but the Brotherhood became part of the revolution as it grew. The real danger is its capacity for reformist compromise, not the Western media's bogeyman of an Islamist, Iran-style theocracy.   

The military council, which rules in the interim period before elections take place, also wants to limit the scope of change, while maintaining the army's influence after the elections and preserving its economic interests (most military top brass are wealthy and have a personal stake in business interests going unchallenged). 

The alternative vision comes - in differing degrees - from a range of liberal and left groups, youth organisations and new workers' associations in the Egyptian Federation of Independent Trade Unions. Many of these are organisationally embryonic,  but they express a widespread desire to pursue the revolution.

Democracy, for them, includes mass demonstrations, independent trade unions, the right to strike, popular democratic forums and women's rights. Democracy therefore isn't simply a matter of getting the constitution right or electing professional politicians to a new parliament, necessary and worthwhile as these things are. It is broader and more participatory than that.

This is the movement symbolised by Tahrir Square: having fought in their millions to end the old regime, in the process creating their own mass democratic assemblies, why should they now simply acquiesce in a Western-style order?

It has repeatedly mobilised, including large-scale protests on Nakba Day (15 May) and again on 27 May, when hundreds of thousands of protestors re-occupied Tahrir. Demonstrations took place in other Egyptian cities too. These, and other, protests have put enormous pressure on the ruling military council.

The revolutionary movement is also raising crucial social and economic issues, like increased pay and job creation. Mass pressure from below has previously forced both democratic and economic concessions from the interim regime, but a huge amount more needs to be done.

The continuing struggle for 'real democracy', to use the phrase popularised by the mass movement in Spain, is intertwined with battles against economic exploitation and inequalities. The main challenge for the Egyptian left is to mobilise large turnouts for co-ordinated protests on 8 July, which link the fight for real democracy to economic and social struggles, articulating a more radical vision for Egypt (and the wider Arab world) than the reformist Muslim Brotherhood and military leaderships.

Mass mobilisations on 8 July can strengthen the partially developed popular assemblies which are emerging as radical democratic forms. They can also provide the basis for left-wing organisations, such as the Popular Alliance Party, developing as serious and influential political players ahead of the elections.

Share

Saturday, 18 June 2011

Radical democracy, popular power and 21st century socialism

I found this talk by David McNally fascinating. McNally is professor of politics at York University in Toronto and author of Another World is Possible: Globalization and Anti-Capitalism (2005).

McNally talks especially about social upheavals in Bolivia (1999-2000), Oaxaca in Mexico (2006) and Tunisia and Egypt (2011). These case studies raise important questions, more generally, about the shape of the modern working class, forms of resistance to neoliberalism, and attempts at radical democracy. I found his comments on the relationship between social movements and trade unions particularly thought-provoking.

It complements Chris Bambery's recent article in discussing changing patterns in working class composition and the nature of anti-capitalist resistance.


Radical Democracy & Popular Power: Thinking About New Socialisms for the 21st Century from CSRCproject on Vimeo.


Share

Tuesday, 14 June 2011

Final declaration of the Forum of Solidarity with Arab Revolutions

Tomorrow (Wed 15 June) I'll be discussing what I learnt at the recent Cairo Conference. The meeting, hosted by Counterfire and open to all, is at the Salsa Cafe on Westgate Road in Newcastle, starting at 7pm. We'll be talking about the progress of Egypt's revolution, the wider Arab Spring, the future for Palestine and the response of Western imperialism to on-going events.

The English version of the conference's statement has just been issued. Here it is...


Final Declaration of the Forum of Solidarity with Arab Revolutions
Cairo, 5 June 2011


In a unique historic era witnessing the victory of popular revolutions and their eruption in several countries in the Arab region, and in recognition of the huge regional and international impact of these first revolutions of the 21st century, Cairo hosted the Forum of Solidarity with Arab Revolutions in revolutionary Egypt. Numerous leftist and anti-capitalist forces and persons from all over the world, north and south, took part in the Forum.

The Forum’s sessions witnessed rich and deep interventions and discussions on the experiences of current Arab revolutions and the challenges they face, as well as the prospects of deepening and extending these revolutionary processes. Discussions dealt with the relationship of these revolutions to the issue of democracy, and the latter’s organic connection to the desired social change based on the majority of people’s self-management of their lives and taking their destiny into their hands.

Discussions did not cover the Egyptian and Tunisian revolutions alone, but dealt also with the main issues raised by popular revolts in Syria, Yemen, Bahrain, Libya and other Arab countries.

Participants agreed on the importance of the left’s firm and clear involvement in these revolutions, and its commitment to build large organizational forms to unite its ranks, and the creation of popular alliances as a basis to radicalize and deepen these continuous revolutions and pushing revolutionary transformations forward in the interest of popular classes.

The Forum expressed its absolute and resolute support for Arab popular revolutions against all Arab regimes of tyranny and corruption, with no exception. It called for building the largest possible regional and international networks of solidarity in support of Arab revolutions.

The Forum also expressed its conviction of the connection between democratic struggle from below and social struggle, and the link between anti-imperialism and anti-capitalism. Regarding the specificity of the Libyan revolution, the Forum asserted its firm support for the Libyan people’s revolution against the criminal Kadhafi regime. It also condemned the military imperialist intervention in Libya, justified by the barbaric confrontation of the Kadhafi regime of popular peaceful protests, calling for stopping this intervention immediately.

Finally, the Forum expressed its complete solidarity with the struggle of the Palestinian people to gain its complete legitimate rights against the Zionist state, which is the spearhead of the imperialist project in the Arab region and part and parcel of the counter-revolution in it.

Long Live the Arab Revolutions !

Share

Tuesday, 7 June 2011

Cairo: revolution at the crossroads

I've just got back from Cairo. Here's the report I filed for Counterfire on Saturday night.

Alex Snowdon reports from the first international solidarity conference in Egypt since the revolution that began on 25th January. It draws inspiration from the earlier Cairo Conferences and has been organised by the Popular Alliance Party, Socialist Renewal Current and other left groups.

Egypt's revolution is at a crossroads. The military council and its moderate allies aim to curb the revolutionary process opened by the extraordinary 18 days of mass protests, occupations and strikes in January and February which led to the overthrow of Mubarak.

Some of those dedicated to extending and deepening the revolution are meeting in Cairo this weekend. Counterfire supporters and other UK activists are among a wide range of international delegates joining Egyptian socialists for the 'Long Live the Arab Revolution' conference.

It is a moment to reflect on the revolutionary achievements, but also to discuss the challenges activists face and plot the way ahead. As a speaker from Egypt's Socialist Renewal Current put it:

"The tip of the iceberg has gone, but the rest remains and resists being moved. Mubarak and close allies are removed, but most of the institutions remain."

The people who made and led the revolutionary events, in Tahrir Square and elsewhere, are not part of the new elite, which is dominated by the military council, elements of the old order and moderate leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood.

The military council and its allies want to preserve relations with the US and Israel, secure its own economic interests and preserve influence after the planned transition to a civilian government. Left wing groups, youth coalitions and new workers' groups are organising to move beyond these limits. As we left Friday evening's session, the tear gas drifted from a confrontation at a nearby police station, where protesters were trying to free arrested activists.

There are continuing struggles over democratic rights. As one delegate posed it: their democracy or ours? A traditional parliamentary republic will not satisfy the aspirations of millions who - through their own historic actions - mobilised, fought for radical change and began creating new democratic forms.

The struggle for real democracy, women's rights, minority rights and freedoms like forming independent trade unions is ongoing. It is bound up with the movements for jobs and better pay.

A striking doctor spoke powerfully about the doctors' militant campaign, which is for improved conditions but also raises profound questions about how far democracy extends in the new Egypt. Many Egyptians now expect a say in all aspects of society, not merely the chance to put a cross on a ballot paper.

Delegates from Lebanon, Syria, Palestine, Iraq and elsewhere have shared their experiences of the 'domino effect' from revolutions in Tunisia and Egypt. Wider developments in the Arab region are a major theme, as is the relationship between Arab revolts and Western imperialism.

Egypt's revolution in particular has shaken Western states and weakened US imperialism, but the military intervention in Libya indicates the determination of US, UK and French leaders to reassert influence. Many delegates have reaffirmed the need to connect Arab revolutionary movements with anti-imperialism, and therefore opposing war in Libya.

How can Egyptians organise to defend and deepen their revolution? What new forms can be built to create a more radical democracy while challenging inequality and exploitation? How can the wider revolts help bring liberation for Palestine?

These are some of the pressing questions which have brought together such a range of activists in Cairo this weekend. They will continue to be the source of intense discussion as the popular movements develop.

Share

Wednesday, 1 June 2011

Cairo Conference 2011: Long Live the Arab Revolution

Tunisia started the revolutionary wave
I'm flying to Cairo in the early hours of Thursday morning for the international solidarity conference.

We'll be discussing some rather big issues, as indicated by the conference timetable below.

See HERE for details of the follow-up meeting I'll be speaking at in Newcastle.  


Friday 03/06/2011

6-7pm Registration
7-9pm Opening session

Saturday 04/06/2011

10-12am The Arab revolutions and democracy
12-1pm Break
1-3pm Challenges that face the revolution in Egypt and Tunisia
3-4pm Break
4-6pm The role of social movements and its future under the revolution
6-7pm Break
7-9pm Arab revolutions on the rise (Libya - Yemen - Jordan - Syria)

Sunday 06/05/2011

10-12am Arab revolutions and imperialism
12-1pm Break
1-3pm Arab revolutions and the Arab-Zionist conflict
3-4pm Break
4-5pm Final session
7-9pm Concert

Share

Friday, 27 May 2011

"This revolution is far from over": Egyptians return to the streets

For background to today's protests, involving tens of thousands of people, I recommend reading Wael Khalil's Guardian piece. The short video report below gives a sense of the spirit and politics of the protests. I'll be arriving in Cairo next Thursday, ahead of the international solidarity conference which opens the following day.



Share

Tuesday, 17 May 2011

From Tahrir to Tyneside...

Solidarity in Newcastle
Here is the publicity info for a meeting in June, which I'm looking forward to speaking at:

Tahrir to Tyneside: reporting from revolutionary Egypt
Wednesday 15 June, 7-8.30pm
Salsa Cafe, 89 Westgate Road, Newcastle NE1 4AE

The international 'Long Live the Arab Revolution!' conference in Cairo, 3-5 June 2011, is a revolutionary summit in a revolutionary year.

Alex Snowdon (Counterfire) and a Scottish socialist activist will be reporting back from the conference and discussing the issues of revolution and imperialism in Egypt and the Arab world.

Please get along to learn more, be inspired, and take part in discussing the lessons of Egypt's extraordinary revolution.

Hosted by Counterfire. Free entry - all welcome.
For more info contact: counterfiretw@gmail.com

See Facebook Event

Related posts: Cairo calling, Register for Cairo Conference and I Witness: revolution in Egypt

Share

I Witness: revolution in Egypt

John Rees discusses the progress of the Egyptian Revolution with student activist Hannah Elsisi, SOAS lecturer Dr Vivian Ibrahim and (in the middle section) Gigi Ibrahim, a revolutionary socialist in Cairo. There will be a lot more discussion at the Cairo Conference in just over two weeks' time, for which you can now register.



Share

Friday, 13 May 2011

Register for Cairo Conference: Long Live the Arab Revolutions

Tony Benn, president of Stop the War Coalition, expresses support for the Cairo Conference:

"The Arab Spring revolt opens up completely new possibilities for our future relations with the Arab world and we must work with the new governments to address the problems that concern their people. The Cairo Conference is a chance to make links with the people who made the revolution and the new labour movement in Egypt. I encourage all those who can to attend."

Around 40 people are currently in the UK delegation (me included), but it will be great if even more people go. The registration form is now available - see HERE.

Share

Monday, 9 May 2011

Revolution and imperialism in 2011

John Rees gave the closing speech in the final session - on imperialism and revolution in the Arab world - at Saturday's Counterforum, which drew around 150 people to discuss the politics of resistance. John concluded with an appeal to attend the Cairo Conference, which I'm just a little bit excited about myself!

The final session also featured Egyptian student revolutionary Hannah Elsisi, rapper and activist Lowkey, and Counterfire's Joseph Daher. Topics earlier in the day included the role of mass protest, what kind of socialist organisation we need, Islamophobia, where the economy is going, and the working class today. All the talks were video recorded and will be shared on YouTube and Counterfire over the next few days.



Share