Pages

Showing posts with label theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label theory. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 December 2010

Against liberal humanism: why Terry Eagleton is wrong about 'the death of universities'

I've noticed various fellow socialists posting this Terry Eagleton article on Facebook. When I finally got round to reading the piece, I was surprised to discover I mostly disagree with it.

This is especially surprising as I've always admired Eagleton, and would recommend books like 'After Theory' and 'The Meaning of Life' to anyone on the Left. His starting point, furthermore, is fierce opposition to the massive cuts lined up for university funding. In that respect I obviously agree.

The problem is we need a strong political basis for defending our universities. We need intelligent and informed arguments, not the historically and politically dubious assertions Eagleton gives us.

He begins by asserting the absurdity of the prospect of humanities disappearing from our universities, comparing this to a pub without alcohol. He says a 'technical training facility or corporate research institute' will not be 'a university in the classical sense of the term'.

I share Eagleton's hostility to the corporatisation of higher education. But why 'the classical sense of the term'? At one time the humanities, as I understand this term (Eagleton unfortunately never defines the term 'humanities', an odd slip for an academic), had no place in universities. Even a century ago most of the humanities disiplines we have today did not yet exist, or were extremely marginal.

What constitutes academic knowledge has evolved enormously over the centuries. How that knowledge is compartmentalised has also changed - indeed it has changed, in what can broadly be called the humanities, out of all recognition in the last few decades. Eagleton fails to acknowledge this. The result is a strangely ahistorical and simplistic view.

Eagleton also indulges a romantic view of the past, which can't be justified by the facts, at the same time as having an excessively grim view of the present.

He writes:

'When they first emerged in their present shape around the turn of the 18th century, the so-called humane disciplines had a crucial social role. It was to foster and protect the kind of values for which a philistine social order had precious little time.'  

Really? That's the kind of soft liberal humanism Eagleton would have once ferociously critiqued. While acknowledging the humanities could be 'ineffectual', this is meant primarily as praise. There's no attempt to justify this view with any historical reference.

Eagleton laments: 'Neither, however, can there be a university in the full sense of the word when the humanities exist in isolation from other disciplines.'

But there's been specialisation in academia for a very long time. The humanities are separated from the sciences. Humanities subjects are separated from each other. This degree of specialisation has increased in recent decades and is certainly nothing new. It is a hallmark of intellectual life in capitalist society, which is characterised by fragmentation.

Eagleton writes 'The humanities should constitute the core of any university worth the name.' Why the core? A case could also be made for making mathematics, say, the core of a university.

Doesn't this unsubstantiated statement just reinforce the separation between 'humanities' and 'sciences', insisting that one of them must be the core? Eagleton also seems to be assuming that 'sciences' lack any critical content whatsoever, and are purely 'technical'.

Eagleton claims:

'If the humanities are not under such dire threat in the United States, it is, among other things, because they are seen as being an integral part of higher education as such.'

This is a rhetorical flourish, with no grounding in reality. The real reason for the difference is to do with university funding. It isn't ideological, as Eagleton implies.

It's a ludicrous claim when you recall the fierce 'culture wars' on American campuses, with conservatives periodically over the last 40 years attacking supposedly 'liberal' disciplines in the humanities (cultural studies, gender studies etc).

Eagleton writes:

'From time to time, as in the late 1960s and in these last few weeks in Britain, that critique would take to the streets, confronting how we actually live with how we might live.'

Eagleton is arguing here that the social critique involved in studying the humanities is the driving force between student revolts. So much for a materialist conception of history - it's a weirdly idealist view, which exaggerates the role of the leftish/liberal academic and grossly downplays economic factors. I suspect the prospect of 9k-a-year fees has rather more to do with it.

It's especially unlikely as an explanation for current upheavals, when most protestors haven't even reached university yet. And don't science, maths and engineering students ever participate in demonstrations? It's true that univeristies can introduce young people to different, and radical, ways of seeing the world, and this is a factor in generating revolt. But let's maintain a sense of perspective.

Eagleton is correct when he concludes that contemporary capitalism is incompatible with the kind of univeristies we need and deserve. But his journey towards that conclusion serves as no basis in the struggle for a different kind of higher education.

Share

Tuesday, 31 August 2010

Thursday, 29 July 2010

Zizek animated: First as tragedy, Then as farce




Also see my piece about Zizek's book 'First as tragedy, Then as farce' HERE and Duncan Simpson's Counterfire review of his new book HERE.

Share

Monday, 31 May 2010

A dash of Lukacs

The second Counterforum is lined up for 19 June (following the inaugural event a few weeks ago). The focus is on Lenin and Lukacs, who amongst other things are the marxist tradition's two great theorists of revolutionary organisation and strategy.

Counterfire has posted chapter 3 (on the vanguard party) of Lukacs' wonderful little book about Lenin, with a brief introduction by yours truly. Here are a three brief excerpts from this chapter, highlighting the importance of an organised core of revolutionary socialists.

Lukacs addresses a common objection to a revolutionary party: the notion that such a party will inevitably become sectarian and aloof, isolated from the wider working class. He writes:

'The Bolshevik concept of party organization involved the selection of a group of single-minded revolutionaries, prepared to make any sacrifice, from the more or less chaotic mass of the class as a whole. But does not the danger then exist that these ‘professional revolutionaries’ will divorce themselves from their actual class environment and, by thus separating themselves, degenerate into a sect? Is this concept of the party not just a practical result of that Blanquism which ‘intelligent’ Revisionists claim to have discovered even in Marx?

This is not the place to examine how far this criticism misses its mark even in relation to Blanqui himself. It misses the core of Lenin’s concept of party organization simply because, as Lenin said, the group of professional revolutionaries does not for one moment have the task of either ‘making’ the revolution, or – by their own independent, bold actions – of sweeping the inactive masses along to confront them with a revolutionary fait accompli. Lenin’s concept of party organization presupposes the fact – the actuality – of the revolution...'

Blanquism referred to an elitist substitutionism, whereby a self-selecting 'vanguard' takes action in place of broader movements. Lenin and Lukacs, by contrast, both stood in the authentic tradition of Marx, who insisted the working class can only achieve liberation through its own self-activity. A revolutionary party, of whatever size, cannot substitute for the mass action of the working class. Later he writes:

'Lenin’s idea of party organization therefore contains as fixed poles: the strictest selection of party members on the basis of their proletarian class-consciousness, and total solidarity with and support for all the oppressed and exploited within capitalist society. Thus he dialectically united exclusive singleness of purpose, and universality – the leadership of the revolution in strictly proletarian terms and its general national (and international) character.

The Menshevik concept of party organization weakened both these poles, confused them, reduced them to compromises, and united them within the party itself. The Mensheviks shut themselves off from broad strata of the exploited masses (for example, from the peasants), but united in the party the most diverse interest groups, thus preventing any homogeneity of thought and action...'

This is a superb summary of the dialectical unity that is the heart of revolutionary strategy. It is the basis for the united front strategy articulated by Lenin, Trotsky and Gramsci in the years following the Russian Revolution of 1917: the combination of a core of organised revolutionaries with systematic work in broader struggles and movements.

Lukacs later explains why it is so vital to get this relationship right, with reference to Lenin's struggle against 'ultra-Left' sectarianism in the early 1920s:

'We have already emphasized that the strictest selection of party members according to clarity of class-consciousness and unconditional devotion to the cause of the revolution must be combined with their equal ability to merge themselves totally in the lives of the struggling and suffering masses.

All efforts to fulfill the first of these demands without its corollary are bound, even where groups of good revolutionaries are concerned, to be paralyzed by sectarianism. (This is the basis of the struggle Lenin led against ‘the Left’, from Otzovism to the KAP and beyond.) For the stringency of the demands made on party members is only a way of making clear to the whole proletariat (and all strata exploited by capitalism) where their true interests lie, and of making them conscious of the true basis of their hitherto unconscious actions, vague ideology and confused feelings.

But the masses can only learn through action; they can only become aware of their interests through struggle – a struggle whose socio-economic basis is constantly changing and in which the conditions and the weapons therefore also constantly change. The vanguard party of the proletariat can only fulfill its destiny in this conflict if it is always a step in front of the struggling masses, to show them the way.

But only one step in front so that it always remains leader of their struggle.'


Share

Friday, 4 December 2009

Talking, analysing, agitating

I spent last weekend at the Historical Materialism conference, at SOAS in central London. Owen Hatherley has penned a brief blog post about it, in which he notes: 'there are enormous amounts of non-organised but deeply politicised people capable of spending an entire three day Marxist conference talking, analysing and agitating on politics, economics and aesthetics without shouting at each other about who expelled who in 1973 or last week and the burning question of whether or not a defunct state was 'deformed' or not.'

One of the sessions I attended was by two Russian artists from the Chto Delat collective. Chto Delat (pronounced Show-de-la) is Russian for 'What is to be done?', the title of a classic Lenin pamphlet as well as being the perennial question facing socialist activists. They showed excerpts from their film-based work and talked about issues ranging from their thoughts about Soviet-era art to their links with social movements today, via such contentious topics as whether radical artists should exhibit work in commercial galleries.

The best session, for me, was on feminism and socialist strategy. Lindsey German combined the topic of her books 'Sex, Class and Socialism' and 'Material Girls' with her experience as convenor of the Stop the War Coalition, talking about women, war and the anti-war movement. She has conducted interviews with women, from various backgrounds, about campaigning for peace and how this political activism connects with their life experiences. She located a number of such examples in the broader history of changes in women's lives over the last century. This talk was complemented by presentations from Greek and American feminist activists, prompting some interesting connections and dialogue (the international character was a significant plus of the whole conference).

Another interesting meeting, again with an international range of perspectives, was the one on youth revolts and student movements. Speakers from the Balkans, Greece and the UK shared practical experiences of being involved in student occupations and mass demonstrations - and the audience included visitors from Austria and California, both sites of significant student unrest in recent weeks. Clare Solomon's paper on the wave of UK student occupations in solidarity with Gaza drew on first-hand experience of having a leading role in the SOAS occupation. It prompted some good discussion about the role of the Internet in spreading action and forging activist links nationally and internationally.

The session with perhaps the most intense debate was on Marxism and ethics, with very different views on how Marxists should think and talk about the question of morality. Alasdair MacIntyre, who has recently become subject to greater critical attention, was a major reference point.

Saturday, 21 November 2009

Karl Kautsky: a cautionary tale for our times

It is perhaps helpful to take a step back from current events and learn from the history of the socialist tradition about political mistakes made in the past, and the origins and significance of these. German socialist Karl Kautsky, influential a century ago, is the classic embodiment of what's known as 'centrism'. This summary draws heavily on 'The Algebra of Revolution: The Dialectic and the Classical Marxist Tradition' (p135-143) by John Rees.

Karl Kautsky became involved in Marxist politics while Marx was still alive. After Marx's death in 1883 he worked closely with Marx's lifelong collaborator Frederick Engels. He edited the journal Die Neue Zeit for thirty five years, from 1883 onwards, and it became very influential in marxist circles internationally. He popularised Marxist ideas more than anyone in the last years of the nineteeenth century and the start of the twentieth.

Referred to as 'the Pope of Marxism', he was central to the politics of the Second International of socialist organisations (which was effectively finished, in 1914, by the capitulation of most affiliates in supporting World War One).

Caught between reform and revolution

However, Kautsky was (in the words of John Rees) 'the living embodiment of the contradiction between reform and revolution'. This makes him a case study in what is typically referred to as 'centrism'. Trotsky, in his obituary of Kautsky in the late 1930s, wrote that he 'occupied himself with commenting upon and justifying the policy of reform from a revolutionary perspective'. Marx, rather more bluntly, called the young Kautsky 'a small-minded medicority'.

Around the turn of the century the German SPD's Marxist principles were threatened from the right - there was a revisionist attitude associated with Eduard Bernstein and others. Kautsky defended the left, including the great revolutionary Rosa Luxemburg, against Bernstein. This meant that at a formal or theoretical level his Marxist credentials were impeccable.

But this only goes so far. As Rees puts it, 'Kautsky could continue to appear to hold revolutionary purity in theory, although in practice the SPD fell more and more completely into the hands of the revisionists.' He describes the split between theory and practice as 'the hallmark of Kautsky's marxism'.

Evolutionary or revolutionary perspective?

Kautsky's attitude to the marxist dialectic - which is central to marxist theory - captured this contradiction. He may have subscribed to it offically, but in effect he drained the dialectic of its genuinely revolutionary content. He wanted, as Rees writes, 'to rid the dialectic of any notion of internal contradiction, of leaps and revolutions in social development, and leave behind only a flat, featureless process of peaceful evolution.'

This 'Darwinian' version of the dialectic was at odds with Marx's dialectic; it became the philosophical justifcation for a retreat from authentically revolutionary practice. Kautsky no longer viewed the working class as - in the words of Rees - 'a class whose struggle transforms it from being an exploited class lacking in socialist consciousness and unable to control the society it produces into a class capable of consciously fighting to banish exploitation and able to run society according to its own needs'.

In Kautsky's deterministic conception of history, people are really pawns at the mercy of larger historical forces rather than active agents capable of making history. Kautsky's weaknesses informed his approach to strategy and tactics for the ostensibly Marxist SPD.

He was most noticeably inadquate when there were sharp turns in events, for example the revolution in Russia in 1905. That unexpected upsurge of revolt illustrated the need for analysis of the world informed by the marxist dialectic, capable of explaining ruptures in historical development. Rosa Luxemburg - consistently a revolutionary and a Marxist, representing the left of the SPD - fared much better in responding to the events of 1905.

Kautsky failed to grasp the significance of the rise of the trade union bureaucracy, and its role in the SPD, during the early years of the twentieth century. He underestimated the political weight of the bureaucracy, in the unions but also regarding its role inside the SPD. This pulled him to the right, so he became a bulwark for the right-wing and bureaucratised leadership against radical critics from the left.

Lessons from Kautsky

This is one of the main lessons to take from Kautsky's political trajectory: too strong an orientation on the union bureaucracies, as opposed to a powerful rank and file strategy, is liable to pull revolutionaries into compromise and conciliation with reformism. This is true regardless of someone's formal commitment to Marxism as a theory. That's another lesson: the need for revolutionary practice to remain aligned with revolutionary theory.

One of the striking features, for me, is how Kautsky had to attack the authentic revolutionary left as part of allying with more (comparatively) right wing forces in the SPD and labour movement. This was the logic of 'going soft' on the right - having to increasingly attack the left. This is what happens when there's a process of polarisation.

It seems to me, too, that Kautsky gave up on what Lukacs later talked of as 'the actuality of revolution', an insight derived from Lenin that recognises the constant latent potential for revolutionary upheaval in the contradictions and crises of capitalism. However distant revolution may seem most of the time, the fact is that it is constantly with us as a possibility.

This isn't wishful thinking - it is rooted in a dialectical understanding of the internally contradictory and constantly changing nature of society. Kautsky, like all centrists, adopted a political practice that was out of kilter with this revolutionary perspective - even if he had known Marx and Engels.

Saturday, 14 November 2009

Crisis, struggle and political alternatives

The annual conference of the Historical Materialism journal takes place at SOAS in two weeks' time. Speakers include: Gilbert Achcar, Robin Blackburn, Paul Blackledge, Alex Callinicos, Ben Fine, Lindsey German, Owen Hatherley, John Holloway, Fredric Jameson, Kim Moody, Leo Panitch, John Rees, Sheila Rowbotham, Alfredo Saad-Filho and Hilary Wainwright.

Here's what the organisers say:

'The annual Historical Materialism conference is organised by the editorial board of Historical Materialism in association with the Deutscher Memorial Prize committee and the Socialist Register. The conference has become an important event on the Left, providing an annual forum to discuss recent developments on the agenda of historical-materialist research and has attracted an increasingly high attendance over the past four years...

One of the principal objectives of the conference has been to build bridges among the various Marxist communities, including the breaking down some of the linguistic and intellectual barriers which continue to hamper the circulation and expansion of critical-Marxist thought. The sixth annual Historical Materialism Conference, under the banner of ‘Crisis, Struggle and Political Alternatives’, promises to continue and take forward this objective.

The conference is organised around three plenary sessions (the Deutscher lecture, the launch of the Socialist Register 2010, and Historical Materialism’s plenary) and a host of workshops dedicated to specific themes.'